Trang chủInternational FootballFive substitutions and the final 20 minutes: the depth bill after the 2026 summer transfer window
International Football

Five substitutions and the final 20 minutes: the depth bill after the 2026 summer transfer window

core_answer: Luật năm quyền thay người, IFAB phê duyệt tháng 5 năm 2020 và chính thức hóa vĩnh viễn từ mùa 2022-23, đã biến hai mươi phút cuối trận thành một giai đoạn chiến thuật riêng. Các câu lạc bộ có chiều sâu đội hình hưởng lợi trực tiếp, khiến khoảng cách tài chính giữa đội giàu và đội nghèo giãn rộng thêm.
key_facts: IFAB phê duyệt năm quyền thay người ngày 8 tháng 5 năm 2020; áp dụng vĩnh viễn từ mùa giải 2022-23.; Chung kết World Cup 2022 ngày 18 tháng 12: Argentina hòa Pháp 3-3, Mbappé ghi bàn ở các phút 80, 81 và 118.; Monaco vô địch Ligue 1 mùa 2016-17 với 95 điểm; Mbappé ghi 15 bàn tại giải.; World Cup 2026 mở rộng lên 48 đội và 104 trận, kéo dài từ ngày 11 tháng 6 đến ngày 19 tháng 7 năm 2026.; UEFA áp trần chi phí đội hình 70 phần trăm doanh thu từ năm 2024; Premier League giới hạn lỗ 105 triệu bảng trong ba năm.
source_attribution: Nguồn: Phân tích của Phạm Đức, Lyon, ngày 10 tháng 9 năm 2026 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn
related_qa: question: Năm quyền thay người có làm tăng số bàn thắng ở cuối trận không?, answer: Dữ liệu hiện có chưa đủ để khẳng định quan hệ nhân quả, bởi thời gian bù giờ dài hơn và chất lượng đội hình chênh lệch cũng là những biến số tác động.; question: Vì sao các câu lạc bộ lớn chi nhiều tiền cho cầu thủ dự bị?, answer: Khi hai mươi phút cuối trở thành giai đoạn quyết định, chất lượng của người thứ 12 đến người thứ 16 trở thành một biến số có thể định giá và được mua như một khoản bảo hiểm, theo Chỉ số Chiều sâu Cầu thủ của VangBong.vn.; question: V-League chịu ảnh hưởng thế nào từ việc mở rộng số quyền thay người?, answer: Cơ hội nằm ở việc trao thêm phút thi đấu cho cầu thủ trẻ, còn rủi ro nằm ở chỗ các đội thiếu chiều sâu chỉ có thêm suất để bịt lỗ thay vì tăng áp lực.

Lusail, the night of 18 December 2026

Minute 80. Mbappe placed the ball on the penalty spot at Lusail. I was standing in the press area just behind the touchline, holding the notebook I use to record every phase of play rather than the scoreline. The Argentinians above me were singing. The French below me were silent the way people are silent in front of a door that has just creaked open. He scored. 2-1. Sixty seconds later, in the 81st minute, he met a short pass inside the box and volleyed with his right foot. 2-2. In the 118th minute he scored his third from the spot. In the 123rd minute, Kolo Muani stood six metres from goal and put the ball wide of the post.

That night I wrote a line in my notebook that later became the frame for almost every transfer piece I have written: that final was decided in the last twenty minutes, by men who came off the bench, on a pitch where most of the starters had run out of stamina by the 70th minute. I underlined it twice, then forgot about it for three years. In June 2026, when the European transfer window opened and clubs began spending sums I could not justify by starting-XI quality alone, I reopened that notebook and realised I had overlooked something more valuable than Mbappe himself: the very stretch of time he turned into his own stage.

IFAB opened a door, and nobody noticed where it led

On 8 May 2026, the International Football Association Board approved, on a temporary basis, five substitutions per match, presented as a medical measure for football's return from the pandemic. The reasoning was explicit: the compressed calendar raised the risk of muscle injury. The Bundesliga was the first laboratory in May 2026, followed by La Liga, Serie A and Ligue 1. The Premier League used it for the remainder of 2026-20, then voted to revert to three substitutions for 2026-21 because smaller clubs feared that deeper squads would become absolute power. That vote was lost. From 2026-23, IFAB wrote five substitutions permanently into the Laws for competitions that choose to use them, accompanied by expanded benches and three stoppages in play.

Alongside that technical door, another one opened. Matchday squads at Qatar 2026 were expanded to 26 players, a number Euro 2026 retained. The 2026 World Cup across the United States, Canada and Mexico expanded to 48 teams and 104 matches, running from 11 June to 19 July 2026, and that volume of fixtures plus intercontinental travel turned fitness from a technical footnote into a labour issue. In October 2026, FIFPRO and the European Leagues filed a complaint with the European Commission over the expanded calendar. Before that, in 2026-25, the Champions League moved to a 36-team format with eight league-phase matches per club, while the 2026 Club World Cup in the United States featured 32 teams.

All of this happened in the same window in which five substitutions became standard. That is why I distrust articles that only talk about Mbappe when a season ends. The real story is elsewhere: when the number of matches rises and the number of minutes rises, the commodity most in demand is no longer the eleven starters, but the eight men on the bench and the final twenty minutes of the game.

An anatomy of the last twenty minutes

Based on my own experience covering matches since football returned in 2026, I divide a game into four states. The first is the opening fifteen minutes, when both teams are still measuring each other. The second is the rest of the first half, when the structure becomes visible. The third is the first fifteen minutes after the break, which I call the assessment window, when coaches decide whether to break their own structure. The fourth begins at the 75th minute and runs to the final whistle, including the ever-lengthening stoppage time that Qatar 2026 established as a new standard.

It is the fourth state that has changed. Before 2026, the 75th minute was the hour of painful choices. A coach had three substitutions, and one of them usually had to be held back for injury, one for a tactical correction, one for attacking reinforcement. As a result, from the 75th minute, teams dropped their block and hoped for what football calls instinct. After 2026, a coach has five substitutions, three stoppages, and a bench of nine to twelve quality players. The 75th minute is no longer the moment of sacrifice. It is the moment of a scripted change.

I call it scripted substitution: the first change at 60 to 65 minutes to alter tempo, the second at 70 to 75 to alter the state of the game, and the last two from the 80th minute onwards to exploit the opponent's temporary loss of organisation. That is something entirely different from withdrawing a player because he is playing badly. Emotion is not the enemy of reason; it is the silent analyst, and the bench is where emotion is converted into decisions.

The archetypal player for that script in Europe today is a midfielder or forward who can sprint flat out for exactly 25 to 30 minutes, who does not need the stamina to last a whole game, and who only needs to be fast enough to attack the space that a defence with 75 minutes in its legs has begun to expose. People call them super-subs, game-changers, eighty-minute specialists. The most accurate description, to my mind, is a bond: he is bought to pay interest at a fixed point in the match.

My notebook, and what it does not say

Across the 64 matches of the 2026 World Cup, I recorded 39 goals scored from the 76th minute onwards, stoppage time included. Eleven of them came from substitutes. The final accounted for three goals in that window, and all three belonged to Mbappe, a man who did not come off the bench but was the clearest beneficiary of both teams having to substitute repeatedly through injury and exhaustion. That is the paradox I want to point at: in the final with more substitutes than any before it, the man who scored three was a starter.

At Euro 2026, my notebook recorded 27 goals from the 76th minute onwards across 51 matches. That figure means nothing on its own, because in football more goals are always scored late than early simply because the second half is longer than the first. What I need is a rate, not a count. And a rate only means something when compared with the same period before five substitutions existed. The problem is that I have no notebook thick enough for the 2026 or 2026 World Cups to compare using the same method, so I have to admit: most of the data I present on this subject lacks a decent control group.

My profession taught me two contradictory things. First, data is never wrong; only the person reading it is convinced he is right. Second, a notebook is not a database, and a journalist is not a scientist. If you read a piece claiming that five substitutions raised late goals by some specific percentage without naming a source, close the tab. If you read a piece claiming that five substitutions changed the structure of the final twenty minutes, keep reading, because the second claim can be observed with the eye, with video, and by sitting down to rewatch the tape.

From an advantage on the pitch to an invoice in the accounts office

There is a lag of roughly four years between a rule change taking effect and it appearing on a transfer invoice. 2026 was the law. 2026 was the money.

The mechanism is simple. If the last twenty minutes become the decisive phase of a match, the quality of your twelfth to sixteenth player becomes a variable that can be priced. And once a variable can be priced, it gets bought. That explains why Europe's leading clubs began spending large sums on players who were not guaranteed starters. In the past, a 40 million euro player who only played 20 minutes a game was considered a failure of the recruitment department. Today he is considered a profitable insurance policy.

The first consequence is a shift in the profiles being chased. Market value is flowing towards versatile players and specialist substitutes rather than towards starting stars. A full-back who can play both flanks and operate as a wing-back in a back three is worth more than a full-back who is simply better at defending, because the coach needs one contingency plan that can serve two different scripts in the same match: protecting a lead and attacking when behind.

The second consequence is money. A squad with depth means a large wage bill. In Europe, UEFA's Financial Sustainability Rules, in force since 2026, cap squad cost at 70 per cent of revenue for clubs in European competition. The Premier League applies a 105 million pound loss limit over three years, a mechanism that has repeatedly forced even big clubs to sell players by the end of June to meet accounting deadlines. In France, the DNCG has the power to administratively relegate a club, and in June 2026 Lyon received a relegation decision before being reinstated in July 2026 on appeal. For a club that once won seven consecutive titles, that is a reminder that squad depth is a luxury paid for in cash.

The third consequence is the gap between leagues. Ligue 1 sold its domestic television rights for around 500 million euros per season from 2026-25, after the previous contract collapsed. Meanwhile, Paris Saint-Germain won the 2026-25 Champions League with a 5-0 win over Inter Milan in Munich on 31 May 2026. When one club in a league earns several times what the rest do, and the law permits five substitutions, that club does not merely have eleven better players. It has sixteen better players, spread across 95 minutes. This is the point I consider most important and least stated: five substitutions did not create a new inequality, it converted financial inequality into an advantage protected by the Laws.

Monaco 2026-17: a 95-point team and the price of selling depth

To see this more clearly, return to the club that taught me the most expensive lesson of my career.

In 2026-17, Monaco won Ligue 1 with 95 points. That side had Radamel Falcao up front, Bernardo Silva on the right, Thomas Lemar on the left, Fabinho and Tiemoue Bakayoko in midfield, Benjamin Mendy at left-back, and an eighteen-year-old named Kylian Mbappe who scored 15 league goals and 6 in the Champions League. I was the man who wrote that Mbappe was merely a product of the system, based on an analysis claiming 78 per cent of his xG value came from Bernardo Silva's passes. I once had a truth I had carved for myself, until Mbappe smashed it to pieces.

What I want you to see in Monaco 2026-17 is not Mbappe, but the invoice of the summer of 2026. Monaco sold Bernardo Silva to Manchester City, sold Mendy to Manchester City, sold Bakayoko to Chelsea, and let Mbappe go to PSG on loan with a purchase obligation. A 95-point team lost almost all of its depth in a single transfer window, and the consequence was that in the seasons that followed they could still perform in a handful of big matches but could no longer sustain intensity at the 80th minute of the third game of a week.

That is the accounting lesson about depth. A club can have eleven starters who match anyone, but if its twelfth to sixteenth players are two levels below, a long season grinds them down not in the biggest games but in mid-table fixtures in February. And this is the point I want to stress for the 2026 summer window: in a season with more matches and more substitutions, a substitute is no longer plan B, he is part of the starting eleven stretched across time.

This also explains why, when I analyse a deal, I no longer only read the transfer fee. I read three other things. First, the contract structure: length, release clause, and how the fee is amortised across financial years. Second, the wage bill, because a free transfer on a high salary may not be cheaper than a fee-paid player on moderate wages. Third, the role: is the club buying him to start 45 games, or to play 25 minutes in 20 games? If it is the latter, every comparison with market value is meaningless, like comparing the price of a truck with the price of a race car.

The V-League mirror: reading five substitutions with Asian eyes

I was born in Vietnam and work in France, so I have a habit my colleagues in Lyon find odd: I watch the V-League with the same notebook I use for Ligue 1.

In the V-League, the quality gap between the eleven starters and the bench is among the widest I have recorded in any competition. There is a historical reason: clubs are limited in the number of foreign players they may register, so most teams pour money into two or three high-quality imports, and when those men leave the pitch, the attacking structure collapses almost instantly. When IFAB expanded substitutions and leagues in the region followed, I sat for a long time asking whether that was good or bad news for Vietnamese football.

My answer is: both, but not equally.

The good news is opportunity. Five substitutions let a coach give more young players meaningful minutes. A nineteen-year-old often lacks the stamina and experience for a full match but has enough speed and nerve for the last 25 minutes against a tired opponent. In a league with few experienced players, that is almost a free development programme written into the Laws. Many European coaches have used exactly that route to blood youngsters, and I see no reason Vietnamese clubs should not.

The bad news is structural. If a club has only three players capable of changing a game, expanding to five substitutions does not make it stronger; it merely gives it two extra slots to send on players who plug holes. A team with genuine depth will use its last two slots to raise pressure, and the difference will show exactly when everything is decided. That is why I always tell readers to watch the 80th minute in decisive V-League matches: who comes on, and why. If the answer is a centre-back entering at 0-0, that club has already lost before the whistle.

Here I want to say something about culture. In Vietnamese football, the word substitute carries a slight stigma. Sitting on the bench is read as being undervalued, cast out, punished. In Europe, being a substitute is a profession with its own strategy, its own training, its own metrics, and a contract designed for it. That difference in perception is the difference between having five substitutions on paper and five substitutions in your head. If you treat a substitute as the twelfth man of a squad, he will play like the twelfth man. If you treat him as the twenty-fifth, he will play like the twenty-fifth.

Three places where I may be wrong

At this point I have to dismantle my own argument, because I have been in this trade long enough to know that an argument presented too smoothly is usually hiding a hole somewhere.

The first is survivorship bias. I remember Mbappe scoring three at Lusail. I do not remember the hundreds of matches that finished 1-0 with twenty minutes of nothing but back passes. A journalist's brain is optimised to recall drama, which is precisely why we must distrust our own memory. If I only log matches with late goals, I have created a skewed sample at the very first selection step.

The second is false causality. It may not be five substitutions that produced more late goals; it may be that more late goals in recent years drew attention to the number of substitutions and attached to it a power it does not have. The real cause could be longer stoppage time, pitch quality, the rise of high-pressing teams whose games break open late, or simply that competitions now contain more mismatches. I have no evidence to rule any of that out, and an honest journalist says so rather than selling readers a tidy causal link.

The third, and the one I want to stress most, is the possibility that five substitutions are being used as a painkiller for a different disease. If the real problem is that players play too much, the real solution is fewer matches, not more substitutions. A fifth substitution helps a coach rotate, but it does not give a player back a day of rest. It allows the system to keep running without being repaired. This is where I suspect I may have been swept along by an argument that favours big clubs, because in the end the biggest beneficiary of an expanded bench is not the player, but the calendar.

From arguing with strangers online, I learned to read carefully before typing. In this case, what I need to read carefully is my own piece.

What I will check in May 2027

I dislike articles that end with a summary. A summary is a way of saying the story is over, and football is never over. So I will end with four checkable predictions, so that you have the right to come back and tell me I was wrong.

Prediction one: in the 2026-27 season, a club in the leading group of the Premier League, La Liga or Serie A will finish with more than 25 per cent of its goals scored by substitutes. If that happens, I take it as confirmation of the final-twenty-minutes argument at club level, not only at international level.

Prediction two: at least one major Champions League club will finish the season with a wage bill up more than 20 per cent, with most of that increase sitting in the group of players who are not regular starters. This is what I call the Depth Coefficient, and I would like VangBong.vn to build it into a standard index for readers.

Prediction three: in the 2026-27 V-League, the champion will not be the team with the strongest attack, but the team with the best away record in the final thirty minutes of matches. I am ready to be wrong if the opposite happens.

Prediction four, and the one I believe most: before the end of 2027, a major competition will reduce the number of matches in its calendar instead of increasing the number of substitutions. Only then will we know who genuinely cares about players, and who only cares about keeping the machine running on time.

And if I am wrong about everything, so be it. The boy I dismissed in 2026 has now lifted trophies in Moscow and Lusail, and I am still holding my microphone to apologise. The only promise I can make you is that I will not turn my own mistakes into the referee's fault.